Today began the efforts to try and get to know the new Mint app for iPad. The concept is great. Once you have your Mint account open, loaded and ready, you can access the information in easy to access fashion from the iPad.
It took about 2 minutes before problems began appearing.
For example:
1. from the main page, it shows December 2011′s “Spending by Category” pie chart. Today’s January 2nd, 2012. We have some pending transactions and I moved a transaction from late December into January within Mint.com to keep the budgeting balanced. In the white table below, it correctly shows the budget remaining and the spending categories we’ve already been using in 2012. There is no way to show that breakdown in the top Window. If you click on the top window, it brings up a larger version of the pie chart and a date selector slide at the bottom. I can select the January 2012 pie chart with the slider, but i can’t keep it there. So if I return to the main menu, it still shows December 2011. Frustrating.
2. The top window can be ‘swiped’ to the left to show the “spending over time” per month. This window shows two interesting things: At first blush, it appears that in October we spent a really HUGE amount of money and that we’re about even (to the good) in January, 2012. The App gives you the ability to then click on the top window (the “spending over time” window) and brings up a black selector box (cool). When we select the Month of October, it shows the massive spend. The selector box shows the number of transactions and allows for the user to select that, bringing up a new window with those transactions (cool). At the top of this window, it shows your total spend for the month, and for the month of October, shows my spend as a POSITIVE of that huge number mentioned earlier. Weird!
It appeared it imported some of the investment transactions for the month, but not others. (In October, I rolled over a 401k, so it should show up as a huge contribution for the new account and then huge negatives for the transactions within the IRA for purchasing funds. Or, it could show a positive in the overview since the value of the account is added to my portfolio. However, it shows a negative). The thought hit me after some time playing with it: Is it possible that since this is a “Spending Over Time” window, all of these numbers are reflective of outgoing monies, so any increase in wealth would show as a negative? So large negative numbers (which are represented by fat, red bars) would be a good thing? That seems counter intuitive.
3. Returning to the top menu and sliding to the left again (so we bring up the “Net Income” window, which is past the “net spending”. I have a huge green bar for October. That, to me, would seem to be a good thing. Now, when you bring up the details (by clicking anywhere on the top window), you get a similar black navigation bar we had to the “Spending Over Time” window. Here, we get more information. It shows (in small white text) income and spending and seems to imply that the difference of those is your net income!
So yes, the second window appears that green bars above the line are bad and red bars below the line are good. In the third window, it’s the opposite, with green bars above the line being good and red bars below the line being bad.
Posted by Ragnar